Jump to content
The Political Lounge

Ranking 21st Century Presidential Candidates


vcczar

Recommended Posts

How would you rank the following nominees and strong candidates? Feel free to rank them according to however you want to rank them. I am ranking those below by who would most and least excite me today, assuming they were at their historic election cycle age in 2024:

  1. Bernie Sanders
  2. Barack Obama
  3. Joe Biden
  4. Hillary Clinton
  5. Al Gore
  6. Howard Dean
  7. John Kerry
  8. Ralph Nader *At #2 if could get 270 EVs*
  9. Jill Stein
  10. Gary Johnson
  11. Mitt Romney
  12. John McCain
  13. John Kasich
  14. George W Bush
  15. Donald Trump
  16. Rick Santorum
  17. Ted Cruz
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ranked by how well I think they would govern if elected in the year they either were the nominee or were almost the nominee:

— Would be good Presidents —

1. Hillary Clinton

2. Joe Biden

3. John Kerry

4. Al Gore

5. John McCain

— Would be middling Presidents —

6. Howard Dean

7. John Kasich

8. Barack Obama

9. Mitt Romney

10. Bernie Sanders

11. Gary Johnson

— Would be bad Presidents —

12. George W Bush

13. Ralph Nader

14. Ted Cruz

15. Rick Santorum

16. Jill Stein

17. Donald Trump

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Cry and seethe liberals:

  1. Mitt Romney (if he wasn't Mormon)
  2. Al Gore
  3. Howard Dean
  4. John Kerry
  5. John Kasich
  6. Barack Obama
  7. Rick Santorum
  8. Ted Cruz
  9. Gary Johnson
  10. Ralph Nader
  11. Donald Trump
  12. John McCain
  13. Hillary Clinton
  14. Joe Biden
  15. George W. Bush
  16. Jill Stein
  17. Bernie Sanders

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1.Bernie Sanders

2.Barack Obama

3.Howard Dean

4.Ralph Nader

5.Joe Biden

6.Al Gore

7.John Kerry

8.John Kasich

9.Mitt Romney

10.John McCain

11.Hillary Clinton

12.George W Bush

13.Jill Stein

14.Gary Johnson

15.Rick Santorum

16.Ted Cruz

17.Donald Trump

Edited by Rodja
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Rodja said:

1.Bernie Sanders

2.Barack Obama

3.Howard Dean

4.Ralph Nader

5.Joe Biden

6.Al Gore

7.John Kerry

8.John Kasich

9.Mitt Romney

10.John McCain

11.George W Bush

12.Jill Stein

13.Gary Johnson

14.Rick Santorum

15.Ted Cruz

16.Donald Trump

You forgot Hillary Clinton

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have decided to treat this as if I were handed a rank-choice ballot election for President. This is my ballot:

1. Mitt Romney 

2. George W Bush 

3. John McCain

4. John Kasich 

5. Gary Johnson

6. Hillary Clinton 

7. Ted Cruz 

8. Al Gore 

9. Rick Santorum

10. Barack Obama

11. Joe Biden

12. John Kerry

13. Howard Dean

The following are candidates who I could not bring myself to rank on the ballot (because I believe them to be both national embarrassments and active threats to the republic and thus will never get my vote for Commander-in-Chief in any capacity) but will force myself to do so for the thought experiment:

Unranked 1: Donald Trump

Unranked 2: Bernie Sanders

Unranked 3: Ralph Nader

Unranked 4: Jill Stein

  • Based 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

23 minutes ago, DakotaHale said:

Al Gore not being elected in 2000 was a huge L and screwed our country not gonna lie

Bah, humbug! You’ve fallen for the classic left wing blunder that says Al Gore vs George Bush would’ve been soooo different. 
 

Spoiler Alert: It wouldn’t have been. 2000 was the peak “Uniparty establishment” days as populists might preach…

Also note Al Gores running mate was Joe Lieberman. 

  • Based 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Barack Obama 

2. Al Gore

3. John McCain 

4. Joe Biden 

5. John Kasich

6. Bernie Sanders

7. Mitt Romney  

8. John Kerry 

9.Gary Johnson

10. George W Bush

11. Howard Dean

12. Ralph Nader 

 

 

 

13. Hillary Clinton 

14. Rick Santorum 

15. Jill Stein

16. Ted Cruz

17. Malaria 

18. Having a kidney stone

19. Donald Trump

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 7/10/2023 at 12:09 AM, Pringles said:

Bah, humbug! You’ve fallen for the classic left wing blunder that says Al Gore vs George Bush would’ve been soooo different. 
 

Spoiler Alert: It wouldn’t have been. 2000 was the peak “Uniparty establishment” days as populists might preach…

Also note Al Gores running mate was Joe Lieberman. 

I disagree. While I do think 9-11 and the War on Terror and possibly a form of the Patriot Act would have occurred, I don't think the Iraq War would have, which means ISIS and Arab Spring, Syrian Civil War might not have happened. 

Domestically, things would have had a more center-left than center-right or right shift. I Gore would have had a more substantial, early start on positive environmental policy especially. 

Now I will admit that Al Gore, most likely, wouldn't be as different from GW Bush as Obama is from Bush. I would suspect Gore to be slightly to the left of Bill Clinton off the bad and he would eventually move further left as the base was doing and as he was doing personally historically.

Judicially, Gore's judges would be somewhat left of Bush judges, if only a little. This would be the case with all of his other appointees. 

In total, while the difference might not seem titanic in size, its cumulative effect would be substantially noticeable for anyone living in the US (if they could also experience the Bush years before trying this alternate history). 

Really, both Bush and Gore were only campaigning as centrists. Gore would likely veer left as Bush did veer right once he was in office.

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 weeks later...

Ranking based on how they'd be as President.

 

John McCain

George W Bush

Mitt Romney

John Kasich

Al Gore

Ted Cruz

Rick Santorum

Howard Dean

Joe Biden

John Kerry

Gary Johnson

 

Worst of the rest (people who either were terrible Presidents, or would be one).

  1. Barack Obama
  2. Hillary Clinton
  3. Donald Trump
  4. Bernie Sanders
  5. Ralph Nader *At #2 if could get 270 EVs*
  6. Jill Stein
Edited by Brunell
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...