Jump to content
The Political Lounge

Favorable or Unfavorable #252: Stephen A. Douglas


vcczar

Favorable or Unfavorable #252: Stephen A. Douglas  

10 members have voted

  1. 1. Did you read my first comment?

  2. 2. Favorable or Unfavorable #252: Stephen A. Douglas



Recommended Posts

SA Douglas (IL-D) might have the most actions for someone who never reached their 50th birthday. The fact that he was so young and influential and ambitious is probably why both Pierce and Buchanan shut him out. Buchanan was doubly upset that Pierce endorsed Douglas instead of him.

For whatever reason, Buchanan has an intense jealousy and hatred for Douglas that was pathological. Destroying Douglas was his top priority. Sectional strife, tariffs, abolitionists, economic panics, etc was all 2nd and 3rd tier. This is a major reason Buchanan was so bad as president. He no ability to prioritize and sense any urgency. Buchanan would have any suspected Douglas ally or supporter removed from even the most minor office. He'd look for them! When it came to important crises he'd waffle. I think going after Douglas was just easier for him, but even then he still lost. He lost control of the party to Douglas for half his term. One could argue he "beat" Douglas in the 1860 election. Buchanan undermined Douglas at all costs there, splitting the Democratic Party. While he didn't like his own VP (Breckinridge), he endorsed him over Douglas, making the split sharper. I think Douglas as Buchanan target is something that gets too little attention. 

I think a close analogy would be if Trump had become president and there was an anti-Trump GOPer that had more support than they action have. Trump, like Buchanan, is more vehement at attacking allies (possibly because he sees them as traitorous, which is worse than being an opposition member opposing him). He demands loyalty, even if it isn't earned; Buchanan was the same way. Anyway, this is supposed to be Douglas's post and it's becoming a Buchanan post. 

His actions:

Douglas, Stephen A. 1840 As 27 yr old US Rep, dines with Mormon founder Joseph Smith, who predicts Douglas will be president one day
Douglas, Stephen A. 1845 promotes railroad to the Pacific
Douglas, Stephen A. 1846 1 of only 4 Northern Dems to oppose Wilmot Proviso, which would have banned slavery in new territories
Douglas, Stephen A. 1846 Breaks w/ Polk and Dems to vote against Walker Tariff
Douglas, Stephen A. 1847 Promotes popular sovereignty doctrine
Douglas, Stephen A. 1847 A leading expansionist regarding Mexico
Douglas, Stephen A. 1848 says admit all annexed Mexican territory as one vast state
Douglas, Stephen A. 1848 says extend MO Comp line to Pacific
Douglas, Stephen A. 1850 managerial role in Compromise of 1850, splitting the package into isolated bills to vote one-by-one on to assure success
Douglas, Stephen A. 1852 seeks Dem pres nom
Douglas, Stephen A. 1853 Denied cabinet office he sought, as admin filled w/ Douglas rivals, like Buchanan; mostly ignored by Pierce until KS-NE
Douglas, Stephen A. 1853 Originates KS-NE Act, which signed in 1854, created Bleeding Kansas by repealing MO Compromise
Douglas, Stephen A. 1853 promotes transcontinental railroad
Douglas, Stephen A. 1854 in Congress junto that hooked Pierce to KS-NE Act
Douglas, Stephen A. 1856 Frontrunner for Dem nom for 14 ballots, and eventually endorsed by Pierce; loses nom to Buchanan eventually
Douglas, Stephen A. 1857 Shut out from Buchanan admin; becomes Buchanan's chief target, over GOP, abolitionists, or secession threat
Douglas, Stephen A. 1857 Upsets North by supporting the Dred Scott decision
Douglas, Stephen A. 1857 key speech against Buchanan KS Lecompton policy
Douglas, Stephen A. 1857 angry showdown with Buchanan over KS policy, calling KS Constitution fraudulent
Douglas, Stephen A. 1857 leads Democratic opposition to Buchanan KS measure
Douglas, Stephen A. 1858 Lincoln-Douglas debates; delivers his Freepoint Doctrine; arguably loses the debates but defeats Lincoln to get reelected
Douglas, Stephen A. 1858 Key influence in getting KS to reject Lecompton Const, enraging South and Buchanan
Douglas, Stephen A. 1858 Gains majority of support of Dem Party with defeat of Buchanan allies in midterm elections
Douglas, Stephen A. 1859 condemns John Brown's raid
Douglas, Stephen A. 1859 leader of anti-Buchanan Democratic faction
Douglas, Stephen A. 1860 Tries to dissuade secession by informing AH Stephens he'd help support annexing all of Mexico as slave territory
Douglas, Stephen A. 1860 Northern Dem nom for Pres, rejected by Southern Dems, leading to a split party and no-win situation
Douglas, Stephen A. 1860 backs the Union cause
Douglas, Stephen A. 1860 deliberates on Committee of 13
Douglas, Stephen A. 1861 Calls for customs union w/ North American nations -- a proto-NAFTA
Douglas, Stephen A. 1861 stages peace offensive to stop secession
Douglas, Stephen A. 1861 Goes on campaign spree to urge support for Union and Lincoln's war effort; dies suddenly of typhoid, aged 48
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ironically, for my usual pro-Illinois rhetoric, there's a massive, massive, massive, like I *cannot* overstate love for Douglas in my part of the state, but I've really trended negative on him overall.  There's a trifecta of dorms at the university I went to (which is only a 20 minute drive away still) named Lincoln, Douglas, and Stevenson, with Douglas under perpetual petition to be changed to Douglass to be fair.  The same city has a "main entrance", so to speak, geographically, and the intersection/stop light there is the corner of Lincoln and Douglas.  There's also a Lincoln Douglas Debate museum in town (as it was one of the sites).

  • Based 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, OrangeP47 said:

Ironically, for my usual pro-Illinois rhetoric, there's a massive, massive, massive, like I *cannot* overstate love for Douglas in my part of the state, but I've really trended negative on him overall.  There's a trifecta of dorms at the university I went to (which is only a 20 minute drive away still) named Lincoln, Douglas, and Stevenson, with Douglas under perpetual petition to be changed to Douglass to be fair.  The same city has a "main entrance", so to speak, geographically, and the intersection/stop light there is the corner of Lincoln and Douglas.  There's also a Lincoln Douglas Debate museum in town (as it was one of the sites).

@Willthescout7 went to this university too.

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...