Jump to content
The Political Lounge

Greatest MLB Players By Position

WVProgressive

By WVProgressive
in General Forum

 Share

Who are the Greatest MLB Players by Position  

7 members have voted

  1. 1. Starting Pitcher

    • Walter Johnson
      1
    • Roger Clemens
      0
    • Lefty Grove
      2
    • Clayton Kershaw
      0
    • Randy Johnson
      1
    • Christy Mathewson
      0
    • Pedro Martinez
      2
    • Tom Seaver
      0
    • Greg Maddux
      0
    • Bob Gibson
      0
    • Phil Niekro
      0
    • Ed Walsh
      0
    • Cy Young
      1
    • Bert Blyleven
      0
    • Warren Spahn
      0

  2. 2. Relief/Closing Pitcher

    • Mariano Rivera
      3
    • Dennis Eckersley
      1
    • Trevor Hoffman
      0
    • Rollie Fingers
      0
    • Goose Gossage
      0
    • Billy Wagner
      1
    • John Smoltz
      0
    • Lee Smith
      0
    • Bruce Sutter
      0
    • Aroldis Chapman
      1
    • Craig Kimbrel
      0
    • Sparky Lyle
      0
    • Eric Gagne
      0
    • Tom Henke
      1
    • Kerry Wood
      0

  3. 3. Catcher

    • Johnny Bench
      2
    • Johnny Bench
      0
    • Gary Carter
      0
    • Carlton Fisk
      1
    • Joe Torre
      0
    • Joe Mauer
      2
    • Yogi Berra
      0
    • Ivan Rodriguez
      0
    • Buster Posey
      1
    • Mickey Cochrane
      0
    • Thurman Munson
      0
    • Roy Campanella
      1
    • Jorge Posada
      0
    • Jason Kendall
      0
    • Yadier Molina
      0

  4. 4. 1st Baseman

    • Lou Gehrig
      3
    • Albert Pujols
      4
    • Jimmie Foxx
      0
    • Jeff Bagwell
      0
    • Johnny Mize
      0
    • Frank Thomas
      0
    • Dick Allen
      0
    • Joey Votto
      0
    • Miguel Cabrera
      0
    • Mark McGwire
      0
    • Jim Thome
      0
    • Willie McCovey
      0
    • Todd Helton
      0
    • Hank Greenberg
      0
    • Harmon Killebrew
      0

  5. 5. 2nd Baseman

    • Rogers Hornsby
      3
    • Eddie Collins
      0
    • Joe Morgan
      0
    • Nap Lajoie
      0
    • Rod Carew
      0
    • Jackie Robinson
      0
    • Charlie Gehringer
      0
    • Robinson Cano
      1
    • Bobby Grich
      0
    • Chase Utley
      0
    • Ryne Sandberg
      0
    • Roberto Alomar
      0
    • Craig Biggio
      1
    • Dustin Pedroia
      2
    • Ben Zobrist
      0

  6. 6. 3rd Baseman

    • Mike Schmidt
      1
    • Eddie Mathews
      0
    • Wade Boggs
      2
    • George Brett
      1
    • Chipper Jones
      1
    • Ron Santo
      0
    • Adrian Beltre
      0
    • Scott Rolen
      0
    • Brooks Robinson
      2
    • Sal Bando
      0
    • Graig Nettles
      0
    • David Wright
      0
    • Josh Donaldson
      0
    • Frank Baker
      0
    • Ken Boyer
      0

  7. 7. Shortstop

    • Alex Rodriguez
      1
    • Honus Wagner
      0
    • Cal Ripken Jr.
      3
    • Ernie Banks
      1
    • Robin Yount
      0
    • Derek Jeter
      0
    • Barry Larkin
      0
    • Alan Trammell
      0
    • Nomar Garciaparra
      0
    • Ozzie Smith
      1
    • Pee Wee Reese
      0
    • Troy Tulowitzki
      0
    • Hanley Ramirez
      1
    • Joe Cronin
      0
    • Arky Vaughn
      0

  8. 8. Left Fielder

    • Barry Bonds
      2
    • Ted Williams
      3
    • Stan Musial
      0
    • Rickey Henderson
      0
    • Carl Yastrzemski
      1
    • Manny Ramirez
      0
    • Pete Rose
      1
    • Ralph Kiner
      0
    • Billy Williams
      0
    • Minnie Minoso
      0
    • Ryan Braun
      0
    • Albert Belle
      0
    • Jim Rice
      0
    • George Foster
      0
    • Matt Holiday
      0

  9. 9. Center Fielder

    • Willie Mays
      0
    • Ty Cobb
      1
    • Mickey Mantle
      0
    • Tris Speaker
      0
    • Mike Trout
      3
    • Joe DiMaggio
      1
    • Ken Griffey Jr.
      1
    • Duke Snider
      0
    • Carlos Beltran
      0
    • Jim Edmonds
      0
    • Andruw Jones
      0
    • Richie Ashburn
      0
    • Kenny Lofton
      1
    • Larry Doby
      0
    • Fred Lynn
      0

  10. 10. Right Fielder

    • Babe Ruth
      3
    • Hank Aaron
      1
    • Frank Robinson
      2
    • Mel Ott
      0
    • Roberto Clemente
      0
    • Al Kaline
      0
    • Reggie Jackson
      0
    • Larry Walker
      0
    • Harry Heilmann
      0
    • Tony Gwynn
      0
    • Mookie Betts
      0
    • Vladimir Guerrero Sr.
      0
    • Gary Sheffield
      0
    • Ichiro Suzuki
      1
    • Sammy Sosa
      0

  11. 11. Designated Hitter

    • Edgar Martinez
      0
    • Paul Molitor
      1
    • David Ortiz
      4
    • Brian Downing
      0
    • Nelson Cruz
      1
    • Harold Baines
      0
    • Edwin Encarnacion
      1

Recommended Posts

jnewt

jnewt

Posted
Posted

Babe Ruth, Ty Cobb, and Rogers Hornsby wouldn't even be able to hit a curveball from Wandy Rodriguez or a fastball from Kyle Hendricks, let alone ones from Roy Halladay and Stephen Strasburg. No way they'd ever be able to compete with some of the other hitters they're listed with.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
 Share
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...